Guaranteed Income Works:Data from Mountain View, CA
Mountain View ‘Elevate’ Guaranteed Income Program
The Mountain View ‘Elevate’ Guaranteed Income Program provided $500 per month in unconditional cash for 24 months to 110 residents earning at or below 30% of Area Median Income (AMI) with at least one child at home. Part of the City of Mountain View’s broader Community for All initiative, the Elevate pilot was administered by the Community Services Agency (CSA), with support from the YMCA and Community Financial Resources.
An additional 131 eligible applicants were randomly assigned to a control group, which received no cash, for comparison. Researchers at the University of Pennsylvania’s Center for Guaranteed Income Research (CGIR) conducted the analysis, and found impacts on income stability, food security, and sense of hopefulness, as well as an emphasis on the importance of remaining in the Mountain View community.
Key Takeaways
-
After 6 months, guaranteed income recipients reported significantly higher household income compared to the control group. This significant difference remained after 12 and 24 months of cash, and lingered 6 months after payments ended.
Income volatility, or the month-to-month fluctuation in household income, was significantly lower for recipients compared to the control group. Recipients reported a sense of relief in having greater stability in their monthly income, especially those whose earnings were impacted by forces outside of their control, such as weather or illness.
-
With an average income of around $30,000 per year, most households were financially burdened by housing costs in Mountain View, which are higher than the statewide average. The recipients of guaranteed income reported significantly lower house cost burdens compared to the control group at 12 and 30 months. They were also less likely than the control group to report health or safety concerns related to housing.
-
Many recipients used the guaranteed income to buy groceries, particularly when pandemic-related increases to the Supplemental Nutritional Assistance Program (SNAP) expired. Throughout the pilot, recipients were less likely to report making food-related tradeoffs due to limited resources and had significantly less worry about running out of food than the control group.
-
The rate of full-time employment increased for recipients as well as the control group. Self-employment and business ownership also increased for both groups, with recipients showing a 7-percentage point increase from Baseline to the 30-month mark.
-
Recipients reported higher levels of hopefulness and a sense of agency over their future, especially in their sense of being able to provide opportunities for their children.
Quantitative data shows the percentage of participants reporting moderate to high levels of hope nearly doubled, from 22% at baseline to 39% at the end of the pilot.
Intergenerational mobility was a key priority of recipients, with many reporting that the cash helped them invest in their children’s social integration, through community sports, school-based activities, and youth enrichment experiences.
Participant households largely hold jobs that are essential to the Mountain View community, such as service workers, educators, cleaners, caregivers, and day laborers. Despite being an integral part of the community, many of them have received little to no share of the economic prosperity generated by Silicon Valley. The Elevate pilot gave these families the stability they needed to remain in Mountain View, and importantly, opened up more opportunities for their children to participate in the community. The innovative partnership with CSA provided wraparound services to help families thrive, plan for a better future, and continue contributing to the Mountain View community.